Fan Favorites!
Don't forget to buy your favorite items!
6.8/10
Pumpkin Pie Wars
2016
84 minutes
Director
Steven R. Monroe
Cast
Julie Gonzalo
Eric Aragon
Michele Scarabelli
Description
Pumpkin Pie Wars is a Hallmark Channel original movie that follows the rivalry between two bakeries in Emeryville, Ohio. Ten years ago, Faye and Lydia opened their own bakeries after a fallout during a local pumpkin pie contest. Now, their children, Casey and Sam, are set to continue the rivalry by competing in the same contest. Despite their initial animosity, Casey and Sam begin to develop feelings for each other.
Professions
Bakery Owner
Settings & Cities
Emeryville, Ohio
Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada
Emeryville, Ohio
Share
Review
Pumpkin Pie Wars: When Baking Becomes Battle and Romance is the Secret Ingredient
If you've ever watched a Hallmark Channel movie and thought, “This would be perfect if it had more competitive baking, family drama, and a love story that rises like freshly baked dough,” then Pumpkin Pie Wars is here to whisk you away into a world where pie baking is serious business and falling in love can happen over a slice of pie (preferably pumpkin, of course).
The movie kicks off with Sarah, a woman who has successfully avoided the holiday baking drama for years—until she is dragged into the epic Pumpkin Pie competition in her hometown (because, of course, every small town has a high-stakes annual pumpkin pie contest). Sarah’s rival? None other than Ben, the charming yet annoyingly good pie maker from the family bakery who happens to be her ex—because why not throw a little romantic tension into the floury mess? In this Hallmark movie, every slice of pie is a slice of life, and every whisk just might lead to a whisked-away romance.
As Sarah and Ben engage in the ultimate pie-off, there’s the typical Hallmark twist: it’s not just about the pies—it’s about reconnecting with family, finding forgiveness, and learning that love, like a good pumpkin pie, only gets better with time (or, you know, with a sprinkle of cinnamon). Of course, we can’t forget the classic Hallmark formula—Sarah’s too focused on the competition to realize that Ben has never really gotten over her, and once she finally does, there’s a heartfelt declaration of love, probably while holding a baked pie (because if you’re going to confess your love, might as well have pie in hand).
And let’s not forget the big dramatic moment: Just when Sarah thinks she’s going to lose the pie contest and her heart, she bakes the perfect pie—because in the world of Hallmark Channel movies, everything can be fixed with a little flour and sugar and the realization that true love is always just one pie away.
In conclusion, Pumpkin Pie Wars is the perfect recipe for anyone who loves Hallmark Channel movies and fall baking competitions with just a touch of romance and a dash of family drama. It’s got everything: competitive pie-making, small-town charm, and enough sweet moments to make you want to bake your own pie—and maybe even fall in love while you’re at it. So if you’re ready to watch two people fight over pies and fall for each other while trying not to burn the kitchen down, this movie is a must-bake! Because, in Hallmark movies, even a Pumpkin Pie War can turn into the sweetest love story.






